Expected Incompetence Enables Fraud
the incompetence makes the fraud less suspicious
I once had to take a last-minute Amtrak journey due to a friend's sudden bereavement. I tried to book the train directly on the Amtrak website, but the website kept throwing up error messages like "online payment not available at this time". So I googled some combo of words like "Amtrak phone number" and got taken to a website that looked like the official one and had a number to call to buy tickets by phone; I called it and the lady took down my desired train-times and email address, etc. This was all slow and time consuming and I asked if I could just do it through the website instead, but she said sorry the website is down a lot and she can't guess when it'll be back. So I sighed, and finished detail-mongering, and she sent me an email to which I had to reply "I agree" in writing, and then a separate payment link for followup.
For better or worse, I have to confess that I didn't figure out that this was all a scam until I got to the checkout page, which was on paypal (weird for a large company these days) and had a merchant name that said something like "created one year ago".
On the one hand, I was stressed and hurried and probably being less savvy than usual – for a start, you really shouldn't google this kind of thing and call a number from a webpage without checking the URL specifically.
On the other hand.... realistically, a lot of people are less savvy to begin with, and when reporting the whole thing to Amtrak I got the sense it's a wide-spread and persistent scam. The Amtrak fraud department asked me to send them links and also "how old are you?", and when I asked why they were asking they kind of awkwardly admitted that this mostly targets the elderly. (For some reason the fake website I got conned by is still up and running without issue, I have no idea why Amtrak can't get it taken down).
What struck me in retrospect throughout the absurd process was that it hadn't seemed implausible because it didn't seem out of place for Amtrak. Oh sure, of course you require me to call a number and then email you. Of course you require me to respond in writing because sending me a payment link. The process didn't seem suspicious because many of my previous, non-fraudulent experiences with Amtrak had involved similar looping and unnecessary bureaucracy. (I'm sorry, everyone-who-works-at-Amtrak! I'm sure you're lovely people, etc). And of course, the whole thing started because the website was randomly not-working on a random Tuesday in 2026, when most commercial websites successfully accept payment 99.99% of the time.
I think this is one of those underappreciated downsides of incompetence. I had a related experience once at a DMV, where I had failed to get my ticket correctly endorsed (or something) and sat for an hour waiting for my number to get called when in fact I wasn't yet fully in line (or something – I still don't properly understand what I actually did wrong).
But the hour long wait with nothing happening didn't seem weird at all because I was surrounded by other people who looked fed up and like they'd waited forever. The fact that the numbers immediately before mine had been called already didn't seem odd because the numbers got called in an only-vaguely ordered order. If you don't have a sense that there's any kind of plan to start with, it's also hard to tell when it's not going to plan.