Are You A Person Who Says Yes To This Question?
for some things, that's all there is
There are two kinds of muscle fibers: fast twitch and slow twitch. Fast twitch fibers help with explosive actions, like sprinting; slow twitch fibers help with endurance activities, like marathons. I am not at all a kinesiologist but my understanding is that most people are born with 50/50 fast and slow fibers, but some people are born 70/30 in one direction or another, and those people will be extra good at sprinting (or endurance), and extra bad at the other.
Now: your inheritance is not your destiny, and both these types of muscle fibers can be trained. If you were born with fewer fast-twitch fibers but really want to sprint, you can train the ones you have and still get better at sprinting. (There's also a bunch of "hybrid" muscle fibers that can go either way depending on what you recruit them for, and presumably many other complexities I'm not aware of). But there's a fundamental physical truth underlying the situation: muscle-twitchiness is a spectrum, and we're all somewhere on that spectrum, and if you chopped open our legs for some reason and biopsied the fibers, you could find out which of us was in which cluster.
Since we don't want to do any leg-chopping, we have to infer what kind of muscle fibers we have by less-rigorous tests, e.g. if you try to jump vertically and you jump real high, that probably means you have a lot of fast-twitch fibers. But that vertical jump test is just a way of figuring out what the underlying biological reality is; the reality of your muscles exists separately from the diagnostic test.
Many other buckets that people put themselves in are.... different, and I'm not sure everyone realises that.
E.g. I've heard people talk about "attachment styles" as if they map to some immutable physical reality, like muscle twitch: some of us are Anxious Attachers, some of us Avoidant Attachers, and if you answer a bunch of questions you can find out which type you are. I think people imagine the attachment test as functioning like a vertical jump test: it's probing a property you have which has a separate existence.
But I think this is a misunderstanding. The attachment tests were developed by 1) asking a whole lot of people a whole lot of questions, 2) noticing which answers clustered together, 3) naming those clusters. The attachment styles survey is not probing some separately existing trait; the answers to the attachment survey is what attachment styles mean. Anxious attachment means "answering this battery of survey questions in a particular way", and avoidant attachment is "answering this battery of survey questions in another particular way."
I hope this goes without saying, but: something can be "a cluster of survey results" and still be a real and meaningful part of your life. For example, if you were to send the world's population a survey with questions like:
how do you say ahoy? a) "hello" b) "hola" c) "ni hao"
what do you call H2O? a) "water" b) "agua" c) "shui"
you would pretty quickly find that your respondents split into three clear clusters. Heck, these people have such startlingly different results that it feels like they're speaking different languages!
But there's no meaningful underlying substrate for this, and if an English speaker learned Chinese they could now show up in Cluster C, because speaking Chinese effectively just means "answering with answer C to every question in this survey".
This really is important philosophically. Having fast or slow twitch muscle fibers is a thing that exists separately from how fast you can sprint, and if you somehow manage to sprint very fast while mostly having slow-twitch fibers, that's very cool but it does not change what your muscle fibers are.
Is it possible that attachment styles are wired in the brain, and physically meaningful in the same way as muscle fibers? In some way I guess they have to be wired in the brain, but then so is my knowledge of English, and I'm fairly sure my English-speaking is an accident of history and not a deep separate truth about me. Is there a meaningful, structural, pre-existing difference in the brains of anxiously attached people from the brains of avoidantly attached ones? It's definitely possible, but I'm skeptical; I know you can get MRI results showing differences between anxious and avoidant brains, but you can also get MRI results showing brain activity from a dead salmon. I think the reality of these classifications is much closer to "this is the language I habitually speak" than to "this is a thing I fundamentally am."
Personally I think this is great! It's possible (though difficult) to learn to speak new languages, and if you do that successfully then you simply are now a speaker of the new language, as much as you were a speaker of the old language before. And the same goes for Love Languages or Attachment Styles or various other things: if you become a person who (honestly, accurately) says Yes to a particular set of questions, you are now "whatever trait is described by being a person who says Yes to these questions," there is nothing else to it. We are what we habitually do, and we can change what we habitually do.